Monica attempts to convince a resistant Rachel to reconcile with Cindi Rose after the fallout the two had at Cindi's charity event. Erika and Derek share their unconventional fertility plans with his conservative family despite the risk of spoiling Easter brunch. Meanwhile, Ashandra may be in over her head after agreeing to help out her church with a public health project that is more than a little over budget.

An elegant Shabbat dinner at Cindi's turns ugly when an unforeseen religious conflict between Monica and Imad sparks another public outburst. Disinclined to attend Cindi's dinner despite an invitation, Rachel hosts a girls' night out of her own with Ashandra and a fiery Elly who's still reeling from the disparaging remarks Monica made about her. Meanwhile, Maribel attracts a suitor after dipping her toes for the first time into the online dating pool.

Already on edge after laying things on the line with Imad in the form of an ultimatum, Monica is blindsided during a girls' day brunch when Elly finally confronts her about disparaging comments she made behind Elly's back. The argument threatens to tear the entire group apart as everyone is forced to take sides. Meanwhile, Erika and Derek receive more unfortunate news in their quest to conceive. Finally, Rachel feels like she has a child of her own thanks to Maribel's latest antics.