At a candy store in New York's Lower East Side, shoplifting happens daily and by the handful. When Scott McDonald and Connie Ribble find colorful ways to distract the staff and the owners see how quickly small items can add up.

At a New Jersey restaurant supply store and chef's mecca, Scott McDonald and Connie Ribble really stir things up by attempting to steal an industrial size blender. Meanwhile, some crafty thieves reveal a few tricks of their own.

In the quant village of Pelham, N.Y., a family-owned grocery store's meat theft problem is butchering their profits. And during a shoplifting sting, a thief gives Scott McDonald and Connie Ribble a run for their money.