Christina and Judy take drastic steps to get the goods on Boyd, whose wicked ways leave a Point Pleasant local in dire straits. Meanwhile, Jesse gets a glimpse of his miraculous past; Terry and Paula grow closer; and poor Meg's grip on reality continues to fade.

Things heat up, as Judy meets a potential new flame at a party in the woods and Christina accidentally conjures up a demon hot to rid her of her darkest powers. Meanwhile, Amber gives Ben a shoulder to cry on after the tape's contents are revealed; and Boyd goes after a treasure that may not even exist.

Meg overhears Ben and Amber discussing a secret concerning Isabella; Christina takes drastic measures to find Jesse after he disappears.