With only 60 days to spare before Philadelphia's historic Church of the Nativity is demolished, the Jay, Markand Dan rush to retrieve abandoned treasures from the past 170 years. The guys hit the jackpot when they find floral and Tiffany-style stained glass windows in the sanctuary, and a giant rose window worth $10,000 has Jay saying 'Amen.' But perhaps their most surprising find is vintage parallel bars and the remains of a basement bowling alley.

The guys are watering at the mouth when they get a chance to explore the former Pabst Brewing Company Headquarters in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Jay is on the lookout for memorabilia and is intoxicated by a blueprint of the factory and a blanket emblazoned with the Pabst logo. Mark spots Captain Pabst's own desk and Dan finds two oak chairs featured in a 1960s beer commercial.

Jay and his buddies take a ride to rural Lonaconing, Md., where they dig through a shuttered silk mill that's been abandoned since 1957. When the guys get in, they discover that the entire mill is totally preserved. With just six hours to dig, Jay, Mark and Dan scramble to find one-of-a-kind items, including a washbasin, a wheeled cart and a custom-built bench. But the building's owner is a tough sell, and Jay must convince him to lower his prices.