On this episode of Haunted Collector, John Zaffis and his team travel to Enfield, Connecticut to visit the home of Jay and Elke Yaple. Since moving into their 200-year-old house, this couple has been terrified by lurking shadow figures, ghostly voices, and the ominous apparition of a man that seems to be targeting their young twin daughters. The team then heads to Elizabethtown, Kentucky to investigate strange phenomena reported at the Morrison Masonic Lodge. Tim Sanders, who runs the historic facility, says visitors regularly hear phantom footsteps throughout the building and have even been physically accosted by an unseen force.

On this episode of Haunted Collector, John Zaffis and the team fly to the Hawaiian Islands for two separate investigations. First, the team hits Lanai in response to a call from Steve Bumbar, president of real estate giant Castle & Cooke. Bumbar and other Castle employees complain of unsettled spirits at their corporate event space on the sparsely populated island. Next, the team ferries over to Maui to investigate reports of a disruptive ghost at the historic IAO Theater.

On the third season premiere of Haunted Collector, John Zaffis and his team of investigators travel to Montgomery, New York to meet with horse farm owner Mary Lu.