A Connecticut woman fears her horses and livelihood are at stake due to a haunting in her century-old barn. Michelle has experienced loud banging noises, scratching coming from inside the walls and unexplained injuries to her horses. Collectibles in the barn include a farming scythe and gargoyles. But during their investigation, Zaffis and his team uncover something far more disturbing that may tie in with the barn's violent history. Then, a North Carolina man reports being tossed to the ground by unseen spirits in his rural home. John Zaffis and his team investigate several odd relics potentially related to the negative energy: crystals, antique swords, and a hearse. The case takes an unexpected turn when Zaffis experiences a 'first' in his 37-year career.

The team heads to Warsaw, Ky., to help out the owner of a 200-year-old mansion along the Ohio River; the team travels to Huron, Ohio, to investigate activity inside an abandoned grain mill.

On this episode of Haunted Collector, John Zaffis and his team head to Boonville, New York to meet with Eileen Esch, who runs a 200-year old bed and breakfast called the Hulbert House. According to Eileen, this historical building has become a hot bed of paranormal activity, and she fears for the safety of her staff and guests. Then, the team travels to Mayport Village, Florida to visit an infamous "haunted house," where homeowner Kay Hurst has been so terrified to live that she's been hospitalized for anxiety.