When Sam becomes third in a string of girls abducted on Glory Island, Mike, Ellie and Rudy hasten to learn the kidnapper's identity. Mike is desperate to find her. They also investigate a psychic who claims to have known that Sam and her friend would be abducted. Meanwhile, the missing girls find themselves trapped in a frightening predicament.

FBI agents arrive in Glory in an attempt to track down a serial killer. Mike is suspicious of Ellie's visiting friend and snoops through his belongings, finding an incriminating videotape. Meanwhile, Mitzi encourages Sara to spend some time with a pediatrician from out of town.

Three young girls arrive in Glory claiming to be vampires. Rudy questions himself when he finds himself attracted to one, and Zane decides to accept an invitation to hang out with them after Sam once again rejects him. When Sam disturbs a body in the lake while fishing, Mike believes the vampire girls are responsible when Ellie discovers that the bodies were drained of blood. Who killed the woman? Her jealous husband, the passionate artist, or the vampires?