Wanting their boyfriends to become friends, Gabi and Sofia organize a double date. But when the guys don't hit it off, their conflict spreads to Gabi and Sofia. Meanwhile, Yolanda meets a handsome doctor when he confuses her with his online date. But needing help to keep up the ruse, Yolanda enlists Elliot and Alan as coaches.

Josh decides to finally reveal a deep secret to Gabi – he's a magician. While initially supportive, Gabi becomes frustrated when Josh's magic takes over their lives. Sofia is terrified to introduce her stern grandmother to her boyfriend. Meanwhile, Yolanda's pen pal is being released from prison, and wants to meet in person.

Josh takes the gang for a getaway on his new yacht, where Gabi hits it off with the yacht's chef, Alex Guarnaschelli. When Alex offers Gabi an amazing opportunity, it ruins Josh's plans. Meanwhile, Sofia has a terrible misunderstanding about her boyfriend and Elliot and Alan meet a flirty steward.