When a sitter falls through Mike brings Mikey on his first date with Valene. Jake and Ami struggle to connect causing Jake to do something drastic. And single-dad Jason invites Sarah to live with him and his 2 daughters.

JJake stays out all night, and an irate Ami wonders if he's coming back; Denise shares a secret with John; Kallie learns how many kids Paul has; Mike and Valene's plans for Mikey's birthday party hit a snag.

Tensions increase as Valene meets Mikey's mother at the birthday party. Kallie thinks about backing out of her trip to meet Paul and his children.