Coop and Carter resort to social media to find Natalie, while his nosy neighbor Diane disapproves of their tactics. Carter helps Diane's nephew, Shadrach, with a personal problem. Coop's assistant, Sophie, hires an event planner.

Coop makes a last ditch effort to find Natalie using a private detective with questionable methods. Carter and Shadrach do some damage control when they break Coop's television.

Coop's latest hookup, Amy, becomes more than he can handle when she keeps turning up unexpectedly. Carter finds himself in a jam.