Dean tasks Benji with selling a house where a murder took place, while Esther uses the real estate to capitalize on people's obsession with murder tours.

Benji and Esther steal a day pass from Dean and gain access to an exclusive upscale gym. Esther meets a poised and successful woman named Nora who inspires her to join her club, while Dean is excited by Benji's sudden fitness enthusiasm and takes him under his wing.

Benji is asked to supervise rehearsals for his former high school's play, but realizes that he hasn't outgrown high school when he comes across a bully. Esther tags along in the hopes of inspiring some drama kids.