Upset that Arthur chose Ronny to be his assistant coach, Sean and Gerard apply for other coaching jobs and wind up competing against each another. Meanwhile, Marjorie becomes jealous when she thinks Ronny has a boyfriend.

Marjorie learns that Jackie's ex-boyfriend is gay, so she tries to fix Ronny up with him. Meanwhile, Sean gives Gerard a birthday gift that proves to be disappointing to everyone but Marjorie.

The family work together to manipulate Gerard into breaking up with his offensive girlfriend, during Thanksgiving dinner.